UPDATED: OC-Born Judge Throws Out 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell'

The government has sixty days to appeal, but may decide not to.

For background on the case and the judge, read below…

Originally posted at Sept. 9 at 8:32 p.m.:


Well, this sort of came out of nowhere. U.S. District Court Judge Virginia Phillips has issued a ruling striking down the military's “Don't Ask, Don't Tell” policy, which barred gays from serving openly in the armed forces. Phillips, deciding a case brought in 2004 by the Log Cabin Republicans, said the policy violated soldiers' First Amendment rights and had a harmful effect on military preparedness.

And get this, John Briggs/Bob Dornan/Alexandria Coronado: The judge is from Orange County.

She's not there now. This ruling came out of a Riverside federal court. But she was born in the city of Orange in 1957, according to the Federal Judicial Center. President Bill Clinton appointed her to the bench in 1999.

Her ruling, which can be read here, orders the military to stop firing service members for violations of “Don't Ask, Don't Tell.”
We've reached out to Lt. Dan Choi, the Tustin native turned headline-grabbing activist who was dismissed from the military for coming out as gay, for comment. While he wasn't involved in the lawsuit, the end of “Don't Ask, Don't Tell” is what he's been working towards.
Update, Sept. 10 at 1:10 a.m.: Here's a statement e-mailed to us a few hours ago by Choi, the highest profile pro-gays-in-the-military activist in Orange County, and maybe in the country:

I commend Judge Phillips, Alex Nicholson and the Log Cabin Republicans for their firm stance in defense of the First Amendment and their unwavering support of our national security. I demand President Obama and Senator Reid do the same, as our moral obligations compel us to strike down injustice and discrimination wherever it exists.

Judge Phillips has forthrightly exercised her unquestionable moral authority and lived up to her mandate to defend our constitution against a most vicious domestic enemy: discrimination against honest Americans. At a time when patriots suffer oppression for simply expressing truth and love, it is morally repugnant for any leader to delay justice based on self-interested timelines of political expediency.

I implore President Obama and his Justice Department to refuse lifting a finger, refrain from wasting any energy, statements, or money defending “Don't Ask Don't Tell” in the court system. His constitutional and moral obligations are most compelling at this historic time.

For reference, Alex Nicholson is Servicemembers United's executive director, and was one of the parties in the lawsuit. Statements from him and others can be found here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *