CHP Wins Approval for Letting Motorists Soil Themselves

Hold it, lady.

The U.S. District Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that a California Highway Patrol (CHP) officer didn’t violate a female driver’s constitutional rights by detaining her from a restroom while she suffered from severe diarrhea, a move that caused, well, a mess.

In June 2014, successful San Diego businesswoman Toni Antonellis had been driving from Ventura County through Orange County on the way home when she felt the onslaught on impending painful diarrhea and broke out in a sweat.

Typical heavy, mid-morning Southern California traffic stalled her ability to exit the freeway near El Toro Road and so she twice impermissibly crossed over double yellow lines for the HOV lane, catching the attention of Aaron Rothberg, a CHP officer.

In her federal lawsuit, Antonellis claimed Rothberg, a onetime bodyguard for Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, violated her Fourth Amendment protection against excessive force plus committed battery under state law by instigating a stop, ignoring her desperate pleas to use a restroom, handcuffing her for nine minutes and causing a delay that ended with her soiling herself in the backseat of a CHP cruiser.

Orange County’s U.S. District Court Judge James V. Selna, an appointee of President George W. Bush, blocked a potential future jury from considering Antonellis’ complaint by handing Rothberg a summary judgment ruling.

In their terse, two-page opinion on June 22, a Ninth Circuit panel of three judges—Mark Bennett (backed by Donald Trump), Morgan Christen (backed by Sarah Palin and Barack Obama) and Ferdinand Fernandez (backed by George H.W. Bush and Ronald Reagan)—claimed that “no reasonable” jury would have sided with Antonellis.

They affirmed Selna’s decision. 

One Reply to “CHP Wins Approval for Letting Motorists Soil Themselves”

  1. I recently tried after the prime control and was pleasantly surprised past the results. Initially skeptical, I create that it significantly helped with my dread and sleep issues without any unconcealed side effects. The oil was easy to use, with clear dosage instructions. It had a indulgent, lusty taste that was not unpleasant. Within a week, I noticed a patent upgrading in my overall well-being, feeling more languorous and rested. I appreciate the unstudied technique to wellness CBD offers and procedure to continue using it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *