Ace Hoffman Is Tilting at 'Nofre

“Do you see over yonder, friend Sancho, [those] hulking giants? I intend to do battle with them and slay them . . . for this is a righteous war, and the removal of so foul a brood from off the face of the earth is a service God will bless.”

“Take care, sir,” cried Sancho. “Those over there are not giants, but windmills.”

—Miguel de Cervantes, Don Quixote, 1605

* * *

The Pacific Ocean gleams like liquid diamonds as I steer my Toyota up the 5 freeway at sunset under a clear, silvery, gloaming sky.

I'm headed home to San Clemente to meet with a modern-day Man of La Mancha (or, in this case, of nearby Carlsbad)—Ace Hoffman [1], a guy in the know about nuclear power, a defender of human life and the environment, a true grand tilter at mighty nuke atom-splitters. Ace's life mission: generally, to end mankind's use of nuclear power, which he equates to the 14th-century Black Plague in its destructive impact on human bodies and society.

“Males in the northern hemisphere are said to piss out about a million atoms of plutonium every DAY of their lives,” Hoffman wrote for a Counterpunch article in 2007. “Just from one 1963 NASA space-probe accident.”

More specifically, though, Ace wants to permanently close Southern California's San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station (SONGS)—or “Nuclear WASTE Generating Station,” as he terms it.

“What,” asks this contempo Don Quixote, “will we do with thousands of tons of lethal spent fuel sitting on that site for at least 300 more years, threatening our lives and livelihoods?”

Opposing Ace is SONGS' owner and operator, Southern California Edison (SCE), a Fortune 500 power goliath ($12.3 billion annual revenues, 20,000 employees) and state-protected energy behemoth. SCE is headquartered in Rosemead, east of downtown Los Angeles, a comfortable 62 miles from SONGS and a good 10 miles outside SCE's self-designated 50-mile “Ingestion Pathway Zone” (IPZ) specified for SONGS emergencies—in other words, Ground Zero. In 1996, SCE made itself the largest subsidiary of a holding company it calls Edison International. Slogan: “Life. Powered by Edison.”

Reality: SCE failed early in the fission fest, way back in the mid-1950s. The company built the ill-fated Santa Susana Sodium Reactor Experimental (SRE) nuclear power plant near Moorpark in Ventura County. Owner Atomics International even fabricated plutonium fuel there. In 1959, the plant's reactors partially melted down, a California first. Fifty-four years later, the Old Susana site remains contaminated.

Edison moved on to build SONGS. In 1968, Unit 1, a Westinghouse pressurized water reactor (PWR) began operations. SCE built Units 2 and 3 in the 1970s (and in a portent of troubles to come, Bechtel Corporation, the nation's largest construction-and-engineering company, installed a 420-ton nuclear-reactor vessel backward). Unit 2 went online on Aug. 8, 1983, with Unit 3 following on April 1, 1984. They've been offline since Jan. 31, 2012, when a “leaking incident” damaged equipment and led to a release of radioactive steam into the environment.

Radiation entered the air, soil, beach, plants and water surrounding SONGS, just 8 goddamn miles from my fucking front door.

My family numbers among the 7.4 million people who live within that 50-mile SONGS IPZ. Welcome to the SoCal glow club, Long Beach, LA, Riverside and San Diego! Eat, drink and be wary.

But don't worry, advises SCE, which claims our biggest power facility has operated peacefully and “cleanly” ever since first fission, providing ratepayers with nearly 20 percent of SoCal's electricity while sparing everyone the deleterious effects of burning coal: tons of smog-producing pollutants and greenhouse-gas carbon emissions. SCE's unstated SONGS business-value proposition: nuclear pollution isn't nearly as bad as coal pollution and global warming.

Ace Hoffman perceives a more sinister scenario about his adversaries, who include SCE, which owns 78.2 percent of SONGS; Sempra Energy's San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E), which owns 20 percent; and the city of Riverside, which owns 1.8 percent. “San Onofre is owned and operated by belligerent liars,” Ace e-ranted to me. “They lie to each other, they lie to the media, they lie to the public, they lie to the NRC [Nuclear Regulatory Commission], and they lie to themselves, thinking 'a little radiation is safe' or even 'a little radiation is good for you.'”

Senator Barbara Boxer also doubts SCE management's veracity. The chairman of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee has called for a new investigation of SCE and a shutdown of SONGS based on information in a document from Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, which built the plan's faulty replacement steam generators, installed in 2010. According to Boxer, the document indicates that Edison and Mitsubishi were aware in advance of potential safety problems with the generators.

But SONGS survives in its South County haunt due entirely to SCE's political prowess and the Big Nuke propaganda machine. The heavily subsidized $33 billion nuclear-power industry is small but powerful because it's really just a money-losing beard for the military-industrial-congressional complex and its $56 billion-per-year U.S. nuclear-weapons programs. The commercial nuclear-power market was invented in the 1950s by the U.S. government to provide plutonium for nuclear warheads. Making electricity for consumers was just an (insane) excuse.


U.S. taxpayers mostly support the nuclear-power industry. In fact, Michele Boyd, legislative director of the nonprofit consumer-rights group Public Citizen's energy program, has called nuclear power a massive swindle of the American public put together by the federal government in collusion with ostensibly “for-profit” nuclear-plant operators. The heart of this fraud is the Price-Anderson Nuclear Industries Indemnity Act, which artificially limits the amount of primary insurance that nuclear operators must carry—an uncalculated, indirect subsidy in terms of insurance premiums they don't have to pay.

Small wonder that SCE writes on its website, “Nuclear energy continues to play an important role in providing low-cost, clean energy.”

True, if by “low-cost,” it means extraordinarily expensive, and by “clean,” it means a highly contaminated fuel that can go kablooey at any moment.

* * *

The prospect of potential disaster at my own uranium-drenched, neighborhood, nuke plant roils my mind about SONGS—and Chernobyl and Fukushima and Three Mile Island—as I head north through the gathering darkness for my meeting with Hoffman.

I began corresponding with him following my 1999 Weekly article “The Death Ray,” about the dynamic area at the San Diego-Orange County border and its secretive military-industrial complex industry in the badlands east of San Clemente. I mentioned San Onofre as a freakish element of what I call “The Valley of the Weird.” As I take a closer look at SONGS, there's no better plant tour guide than Hoffman.

A plethora of Orange County and San Diego groups has sprung up to fight SONGS over the years—the most active include Don Leichtling's Decommission San Onofre, Gary and Laurie Headrick's San Clemente Green, Gene Stone's Residents for a Safe Environment (ROSE), Donna Gilmore's San Onofre Safety, and Ray Lutz's Citizens Oversight Projects (COPs). But it's Hoffman who has captured the public's imagination. NASA's 1997 launch to Saturn of its Cassini-Huygens robotic orbiter powered by 72 pounds of plutonium-238 motivated him to graduate from mere letter-writing to local San Diego-area newspapers to loud activism. And then in 2001, on the same day that SCE told the media that activists such as Hoffman “don't understand the laws of physics,” workers at the SONGS plant, in an apparent failure to comprehend the laws of gravity, dropped an 80,000-pound crane.

“The comment and the crane were the downfall of SanO, which became my sole focus,” recalls Hoffman. “Having fought a planetary attack by NASA, I decided to follow the 'think global, act local' creed and concentrate my activities on shutting down the plant. That was more than a million pounds of nuke waste ago.”

In 2008, Hoffman was diagnosed with bladder cancer. Because he never smoked, he suspected radiation as the cause. He decided to make a contribution of the knowledge about fighting nuclear power he had accumulated during 40 years of anti-nuke research, publishing what many in the movement rank among the most important and accessible textbooks of the Nuclear Age, The Code Killers: Why DNA and ionizing radiation are a dangerous mix . . . An expose of the nuclear industry. You can buy it from his frequently updated blog, Ace Hoffman's Nuclear Failures Report (

Hoffman's thesis: nuclear-power plants produce immensely damaging ionizing radiation (from gamma rays and the alpha or beta particles emitted by decaying radioactive elements), which emits enough energy to break countless chemical bonds in the human body's 50 trillion to 100 trillion cells. Exposure to ionizing radiation can alter cell DNA, which expresses as birth defects and cancer. According to Hoffman, ubiquitous nuke plants and their radioactive output—the byproducts of uranium atomic fission—wreak havoc on bodies, destroying our tissues, organs and bones, sickening and killing us.

He's no desk-bound academic. His book is a polemic to employ as a weapon in the battle against nuclear power. As such, it places the author squarely in the middle of an ever-expanding, national, anti-nuke movement, one in which he's become a sort of Cassandra: Last year, SONGS was shut down due to “the leaking incident.” For Hoffman, what began with writing letters to the editor and providing the lone voice of opposition at regulatory meetings has become a “storm of activism,” as increasing numbers people seek him out to learn about the dangers of nuclear power, in general, and, in particular, the truth about San Onofre.

* * *

The junior Einsteins who run dumps such as SONGS are brilliant at controlling nuclear fission and making water really, REALLY HOT, enough to spin wheels and make electricity. From there, though, even they will admit to utter cluelessness.


“Radioactive decay is not triggered . . . and therefore, science does not know how to control it,” explains Dr. Gordon Edwards, president of the Canadian Coalition for Nuclear Responsibility (CCNR). “We have no mechanism for speeding up, slowing down, starting or stopping radioactive decay. That's why radioactive wastes are such an enormous problem. If radioactive particles escape into the environment and enter the human body, they destroy cells. It's like throwing a grenade into a computer.”

According to Physicians for Social Responsibility, nuclear fuel is “dirty,” dangerous and deadly throughout its life cycle—mining, refining, purifying, using and burying. The core of a nuclear reactor contains both water and assemblies of fuel rods clad in zirconium and containing ceramic pellets of uranium-235-enriched nuclear fuel. This fuel is bombarded with neutrons to set off controlled nuclear reactions. These reactions super-heat the water, creating 550-degree Fahrenheit steam, which powers a turbine, generating electricity.

Unfortunately for all life on Earth, this process also creates poisons—uranium's hellish bastard “daughters.” The approximate half-lives of some of the isotopes in spent nuclear fuel: strontium-90, 28 years; cesium-137, 30 years; plutonium-239, 24,000 years; cesium-135, 2.3 million years; iodine-129, 15.7 million years. The spent fuel rods from a nuclear reactor are the most radioactive of all nuclear wastes, giving off 99 percent of the total radiation. This waste requires isolation from our ecosystem for 10,000 to 100,000 years before it sufficiently deteriorates due to natural radioactivity.

Spent fuel rods are removed from reactors and placed in crowded (with other rods), 35-foot deep pools of water and allowed to cool down for five to 10 years before being moved into “dry cask” storage. These casks—SONGS hosts about four dozen—are 20 feet tall, 10 feet wide and weigh 100 tons, 15 tons of which is used reactor core assemblies.

Then the casks . . . sit, biding their smoldering time, of which they have plenty. SONGS has accumulated 2,000 tons to 4,000 tons of the vile stuff, and if it ever catches fire, it can explode and shoot potentially fatal debris into our air and water. SCE's take?

“The NRC has determined this storage technology is safe for at least 100 years. The best location for a central, U.S. nuclear-waste depository is a matter of continuing political debate. But there is settled science supporting the long-term safety of deep, geologic disposal.”

Note how SCE has made SONGS' spent fuel a 2113 problem. And “settled” by whom? We've only been burying this junk since 1942, when the first self-sustaining nuclear chain reaction took place. Moreover, no permanent storage site exists for spent nuclear fuel. The feds reneged on promises to haul it away. And the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) issued a report in August 2012 that declared, “Spent nuclear fuel . . . is one of the most hazardous substances created by humans.”

The U.S. can't dispose of the nearly 70,000 metric tons of spent fuel currently stored in 33 states from 104 reactors at 64 plants. It was supposed to go to a repository located deep under Nevada's Yucca Mountain ($10 billion down that hole to date), but Nevadans refuse to risk turning their state into a radioactive, nuclear cauldron. The GAO found that new facilities would take up to 40 years before they could accept spent fuel. Meanwhile, spent fuel stored onsite at commercial nuclear plants increases by about 2,000 metric tons annually.

For something with such a monumentally negative impact, uranium-pellet-filled fuel rods don't deliver much value—each produces energy for only six years, and according to SCE, nuclear plants use only 5 percent of the fuel's energy. It's not low-cost, clean energy—but it is wildly inefficient.

* * *

I speed through the winding emptiness of the 200-square-mile Marine Corps Base Camp Pendleton, which owns the tract of land SONGS occupies. Oh, those jarheads . . .

Camp Pendleton emerged in 1942 when the U.S. government—reeling in panic from Pearl Harbor—essentially confiscated 122,798 acres of Rancho Santa Margarita y Las Flores from its owners and created the country's largest Marine Corps base. In May 1964, the Department of the Navy granted SCE a 60-year easement for use of the site to build and operate SONGS.

Construction of Units 2 and 3 spanned a decade, going beyond the budget by billions of dollars because of earthquake-related design revisions and regulatory delays. The final price at startup for the two reactors totaled $4.5 billion, according to the California Council on Science and Technology. The pricey corpses of both units' cores will fester onsite forever. After operating Unit 1 for 24 years, SCE decommissioned and dismantled it in 1992 because it didn't want to spend $125 million in required modifications. The old reactor remains onsite, cocooned in concrete and still as radioactive as hell.


When I phoned the Marines to ask about protecting the base's daytime population of 70,000, I was told to call SCE. Later, I did find a brochure on the base website explaining evacuation procedures should SONGS experience an emergency.

I zip through the unmanned California Highway Patrol-U.S. Border Patrol San Onofre traffic checkpoint, come up over a rise, and there it is: SONGS. It looms on my left, next to the Pacific Ocean, which backdrops the plant's familiar, 160-foot, twin, hemispherical, concrete containment towers. (Yeah, I know: They look like Hollywood bolt-on breast implants, but I'm not playin'.) The place is squat, gray and homely in a haute gauche, bleak-noir, industro-power-plant style, 45 years ancient and well past its “close by” date. In 2000, Edison wrangled license extensions to 2020. The containment structures for both units are made of 4.5-foot-thick reinforced concrete. Inside each structure is an 8-inch-thick steel reactor vessel that houses the reactor.

The incongruity of seeing this woeful monstrosity on that magnificent shore always stuns. An aged, “embrittled,” crumbling relic of the U.S. government's 1950s and 1960s nuclear-power-plant-building mania, SONGS hunkers forlorn and ugly in a seismic fault zone near San Clemente's south end on 84 acres of beautiful beachfront . . . now irredeemably lost.

'Nofre's a defiled dragon's lair of nuclear detritus—the flow of the global-nuclear-waste stream dead-ended here, never to go away. But now it's lit up to make the domes, outbuildings, poles, pipes, wires, cyclone fence, brick security wall, et al., look bright and beguiling at dusk. Here's a house that knows how to pay a light bill.

Increasingly, though, there are fewer and fewer folks home, as the place empties out. In August 2012, SCE cut 730 employees, taking the plant workforce down to 1,500—job-loss hits to the local economy that will only continue.

Along with the domes, I can see turbines, outflow/intake pipes, a too-low sea wall, control-room areas, a switchyard, an emergency diesel generator room (all bunched up), water-storage tanks for the emergency cooling systems and, the BIG trouble here, spent-fuel pool areas and dry-storage casks. Trestles surfers and San Onofre State Beach campers see this gruesome sight every day, with little comprehension of its magnitude as an economic, ecological disaster.

SONGS squanders heat on an unimaginable scale, dissipating enough into the sky above the plant each day to warm a city for a year. A 1994 Friends of the Earth study showed that a nuke plant must operate for 18 years before realizing 1 net calorie of energy. The nuke never pays off.

'Nofre lays its worst punishments on the ocean. To cool the reactors, it sucks in 2 million gallons of ocean water every minute, 1.6 billion gallons each day—an intake equal to a lake-sized square mile of ocean 12 feet deep. This prodigious misuse of water devastates local sea life. The Sierra Club calls SONGS and its sister California nuke plant Diablo Canyon “Giant Fish Blenders.” At San Onofre each year, 121 tons of midwater fish are entrained (sucked into the cooling system itself). Unit 3 alone annually entrains an average of more than 3.1 billion individual aquatic organisms.

SONGS is a major polluter. “The Radioactive Effluent and Environmental Reports for San Onofre Units 2 and 3, 2005-2011” reveals in-depth details about the plant's impact on the environment. It has state and federal permission to release its “radwaste” into the air and water. In 2010, Edison piped highly diluted radwaste into the ocean for 550 hours (while releasing numerous low-level radionuclides into the air for a total of 44 hours). Edison's documents provided to the NRC reveal that SONGS released 34 different radionuclides, including plutonium, strontium-90 and cesium-137, all extremely injurious to living tissue.

Then there are “accidents.” In 2006, tritium reportedly leaked into the groundwater beneath San Onofre, prompting the temporary closure of one area drinking-water well.

And SONGS isn't such a great place to work. On March 2, 2010, the NRC sent SONGS managers a letter describing a “chilling effect” among plant employees who feared retaliation from management if they reported safety concerns.

San Onofre has a filthy physical environment, “full of dirt, trash, clutter, cigarette butts and unidentified tripping hazards,” according to Bethann Chambers, wife of SONGS whistleblower James Chambers, who worked at Units 2 and 3. “The (work) culture at SONGS is sick,” she wrote on Dec. 9, 2010, in a long online post titled “The Truth About San Onofre From the Wife of a Licensed Nuclear Reactor Operator.”

“This is the best word to describe the toxic work environment at the plant,” added Chambers, who characterized the SONGS workforce as “three-tiered”—a management “Good Old Boys Club” (because it includes very few women) at the top, a second tier of “Company Stooges” and a bottom tier of “Worker Bees.”


The result, according to Chambers: “If the workers at the nuclear-power plant are afraid to raise concerns, then the health and safety of the public is in jeopardy.”

In addition to the shutdown, 2012 brought SONGS more drama than a Kardashian-Olsen twins cage match. In January, an outside contractor who was leaning over to retrieve a flashlight while working near Unit 2's reactor pool lost his balance and fell in. He survived. In May, Edison revealed a case of flawed safety equipment and lax oversight regarding the reactors' emergency-backup generators. The next month, a routine NRC inspection of SONGS found “security deficiencies.” In December, fearing possible “employee-related sabotage,” SONGS officials began investigating why they found coolant mixed with oil in their safety equipment.

Imagine a delinquent 8-year-old behind the wheel of the 700 mph turbojet-propelled Fossett LSR hypercar packed tight with nuclear explosives, trying to set a world land-speed record, 24/7 for eternity. That's SONGS.

But none of the above forced the current shutdown. Dumb, doomed, double-domed SONGS has been closed for a year thanks to that ” leaking incident,” which involved heat-transfer tubes in the plant's Unit 3 nuclear-reactor steam generators. These convert heat from the reactor cores into steam to drive turbines and generate electricity. Tubes in a year-old, poorly designed, 65-foot tall, 640-ton steam generator ruptured.

SCE downplayed the shutdown “incident” in a June 7 press release last year. “Both SONGS units are currently safely shut down for inspections, analysis and testing. Unit 2 was taken out of service Jan. 9 for a planned outage. Unit 3 was safely taken offline Jan. 31 after station operators detected a leak in a steam-generator tube.”

What actually took place was that several heat-transfer tubes, severely damaged by extended heavy vibration and denting, burst and vented hundreds of gallons of super-heated, highly pressurized, radioactive steam. Alarms sounded, and operators scrambled far into the next day before finally doing a “cold” shutdown of the entire system. They had to evacuate the turbine plant and surrounding areas and declare an “Alert” (“an event that could decrease the plant's level of safety,” in SONGSspeak).

“Edison played fast and loose by making radical design changes and ducking the rules,” said Kendra Ulrich, nuclear campaigner with Friends of the Earth. “The result was the most rapid breakdown of such replacement steam generators in the history of the U.S. nuclear industry. If Edison had followed the rules, an NRC license review would have found these glaring defects, and the lives of millions of people would not have been put at risk, nor would hundreds of millions of dollars have been squandered.”

Edison sees things differently. In June 2012, SCE executives claimed that the cause of what they call the “unexpected” tube-to-tube wear was “fluid elastic instability” or excessive tube vibration. That's like saying a decked prizefighter got knocked out by the canvas when his head hit it.

* * *

I cross under SONGS' overhead power lines that trail off into the hills, and in a 65-mph instant, I'm happily past the gnarly old plant and rolling toward San Clemente, beauty to 'Nofre's beast. I park in an unremarkable parking lot and head into our meeting place. I inhale the aromas of warm, delicious Mexican food being enjoyed by a noisy dinner-hour crowd. It's early for our meeting, so I grab a table in the back of the restaurant and order coffee. The stack of materials in my folder has a slick, four-color brochure from SCE titled “Emergency Preparedness Information for the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station (SONGS).”

SCE's emergency master plan? Listen for the sirens—a long, steady, continuous, oscillating, awful, blaring wail—sounding for two to five minutes each time, turn on the radio or TV (DO NOT call 911!), swallow potassium-iodide pills (which residents of San Clemente, Dana Point and San Juan Capistrano can get free of charge from those cities), and then head out into the monumental, immobile traffic jam that will be blocking the few roads out of town. Unwritten tips: abandon car, start walking, avoid airborne radioactive plume, head for desert as though the mad hermit namesake of 'Nofre, Onuphrius himself, don't return for 10,000 years.

I look over my notes on Hoffman: age 55, a Connecticut native, the son of professors, some college, an elopement with wife Sharon. He moved here in 1991, first setting eyes on San Onofre while driving south on the 5 freeway.

“I remember thinking, 'That's a nuclear reactor. What's it doing HERE?'” he wrote in an email.

He's still searching for the answer. For years, Hoffman has been studying California's energy issues. A computer programmer and software designer, he owns and operates the Animated Software Co., which specializes in educational software.

As he comes through the door, I recognize Hoffman from his online photo: a middle-aged engineer; 6 feet tall; 175 pounds; blue eyes; a days-old beard; short, brownish-blond hair sprinkled with gray and parted on the left. He's casually dressed in jeans and an open-collar cotton shirt. He arrives in the company of his petite, smiling wife and a man whom Hoffman introduces as Torgen Johnson of Solano Beach. The trio belongs to the DAB Safety Team, an anti-SONGS group that speaks out publicly against the plant.


“If you had to sum up your message to the people of Southern California, what would it be?” I ask.

“It's simple,” Hoffman says, jabbing his fork above his plate for emphasis. “Nuclear power kills.”

He looks around the room at the laughing, talking families eating their meals. “Thousands have already died from Chernobyl, and thousands will die from Fukushima, but their deaths are scattered in time and all over the planet, and so the 'health physicists' ignore those deaths, denying any connection to any nuclear accident,” he continues. “But realistic data by highly qualified scientists, in study after study, proves the connection beyond doubt. So don't make San Onofre another Fukushima. San Onofre is shut down now. Let's keep it that way.”

What's going on at SONGS?

“San Onofre is currently shut down because its steam generators are busted,” Hoffman says. “But that's not all that's wrong.” He begins ticking off some demerits: “Its fuel pools are full. It's in a tsunami inundation zone AND an earthquake zone. It's old and decrepit. Its employees are intimidated by management and falsify reports and are afraid to report safety problems. Management likewise has its back against the wall and is desperate to prove it can restart the reactors somehow, despite the engineering logic against it. Nobody wants to lose face or a job. Every state agency claims only the NRC can 'force' San Onofre to close, and the NRC has never met a nuclear power plant it didn't like.”

What can ordinary people do about this?

“The citizens who don't want Fukushima USA to happen here are in a bind, that's for sure,” he says. “But dry casks aren't the solution. Shutdown is the most important and only logical next step.”

What compelling reasons does SCE have to keep the old place going?

“When San Onofre is operating, it's 'easy money' for SCE,” Hoffman says. “The reactors, when operating, produce $1 million per day in revenue for their owners. That clouds their thinking. All for a bit of electricity, which is easily obtained in safer ways.”

Security is always an issue at SONGS. The place sits right next to a major freeway. It's on the water. It's directly beneath the San Diego-LA airports' flight path. Two of the 9/11 al-Qaeda hijackers drove by on their way to the airport. I saw an ad for a security guard at the plant that required only a GED.

“Nuclear-power plants are likely to be targets of terrorist attacks in that they are considered a legitimate target of war as defined by the United States military,” Hoffman adds. “We bombed power-generation systems in Iraq, Kosovo and Afghanistan. Furthermore, we used nuclear weapons—depleted uranium—and caused widespread environmental damage. Lastly, every military scholar knows that the best way to cripple a force is to wound as many of the enemy as possible. Destroying San Onofre would do that. People would die, but slowly, and caregivers would be severely strained around the country from just one radiological catastrophe.”

As I listen to Hoffman's surprisingly calm and measured responses, I keep waiting for the passionate flamethrower who sends those lit-up emails and posts those angry anti-nuker denunciations. But I'm not seeing or hearing any bold bitterness, harsh outbursts or rage against the nuke machine. Instead, here's a polite guy with a good sense of humor and an engineer's composed, analytical air. In conversation, Hoffman uses logic to examine a situation; he seems to appreciate and respect any displays of intelligence in his adversaries. He comes across as an ordinary man who just wants to help solve one of the planet's biggest problems.

Hoffman's demeanor is testing my Don Quixote comparison—no trace in this guy of the gaunt, slightly mad ascetic set on bringing order to a tumultuous world. I ask him what he thinks of the Don Quixote analogy.

He laughs. “Well, nuclear power plants aren't an imaginary enemy, but even so, the lance would be a laser and the horse a mountain bike. Other than that . . .” He trails off, smiling.

I pitched this story as an interview with Ace Hoffman, reigning champion of the fight against San Onofre, I tell him. Does he agree?

He laughs. “Reigning champion . . . champion of what? It's the team that is a hundred times more powerful than I ever was by myself, but besides that, we haven't actually won anything, so I'm the champion of nothing!


I received no response from SCE's media department to my phone calls and email messages seeking comment about Hoffman and his SONGS-related activities. So I ask Hoffman instead: What do the folks at Edison think of you?

Another broad grin. “They say, 'We love you, Ace!'”


[1] Ace Hoffman changed his legal name several years ago, after the author already knew him. A correction was made to this story on Feb. 21, 2013.

6 Replies to “Ace Hoffman Is Tilting at 'Nofre”

  1. To be able to differentiate the loved one ages of rocks from such old product, as well as to get a far better time resolution than that available from long-lived isotopes, temporary isotopes that are no much longer present in the rock can be used. These females are excellent for marriage, so you better not miss your chance to find your future soulmate online. A prime instance would be just how people used to count on matchmakers, adjusting to rigid tribal and familial criteria, whereas today, they just have the freedom of option to find as well as pick companions by themselves. The majority of cities in China have a local government that restricts foreigners from staying within its city restrictions. Nevertheless, regional eruptions of volcanoes or various other occasions that produce huge amounts of carbon dioxide can reduce local focus of carbon-14 and also offer incorrect days. China is an extra typical nation, which isn’t always terrific for regional girls who wish to follow their interests instead of continuously staying at home as well as taking care of kids. It is really as much as you as to whether you are trying to find relationship, romance, dating, love or simply others who you might get in touch with for actually any kind of personal factor of your own.

    However while dating seems to be growing, marriage is still unusual-thanks to political differences that are commonly irreconcilable, according to the females I spoke with, who were all between 21 as well as 25, prime age to begin looking for an other half in China. Collectively called the Pahiyangala Man, the skeletal remains tell of a human figure with a large jaw bone, big teeth and a huge scheme while the vertebral framework was also dramatically shorter in length. Of those 7, 4 stand for inland areas, while Braille is a guideline to medicare concerns. Normally a shorter half-life causes a greater time resolution at the expenditure of timescale. This is based upon the beta degeneration of rubidium-87 to strontium-87, with a half-life of 50 billion years. In other radiometric dating approaches, the heavy moms and dad isotopes were created by nucleosynthesis in supernovas, suggesting that any kind of moms and dad isotope with a brief half-life need to be extinct by currently. For rocks going back to the start of the planetary system, this needs incredibly long-lived moms and dad isotopes, making measurement of such rocks’ precise ages inaccurate. With interest, sincerity as well as development they are aimed to aid members to address all the problems throughout the on-line dating.

    On the site participants can send Cupid Note, receive Admirer mail from Chinese ladies, send out EMF e-mails, conversation cope with them, make phone call, send blossoms & present as well as request to fulfill Russian lady. The petite figure, lovely eyes, and flawless skin make a Chinese lady extremely adorable. review Now you can see that dating and also marrying Chinese partner is not that challenging. Therefore both a high time as well as the approximate age resolution can be acquired. This makes carbon-14 a perfect dating technique to date the age of bones or the remains of an organism. This plan is made use of to date old igneous and metamorphic rocks, and also has additionally been made use of to date lunar examples. This scheme has application over a vast array of geologic dates. The scheme has a variety of a number of hundred thousand years. For dates up to a couple of million years micas, tektites (glass fragments from volcanic eruptions), as well as meteorites are best utilized. The releases of co2 into the biosphere therefore of automation have actually additionally depressed the percentage of carbon-14 by a couple of percent; in comparison, the amount of carbon-14 was raised by above-ground nuclear bomb tests that were carried out right into the early 1960s. Likewise, a boost in the solar wind or the Planet’s magnetic area over the existing worth would depress the quantity of carbon-14 developed in the atmosphere.

    Carbon-14, though, is continually created with crashes of neutrons generated by cosmic rays with nitrogen in the upper atmosphere as well as thus stays at a near-constant level in the world. Journal of African Earth Sciences. American Journal of Science. Yearly Evaluation of Nuclear Science. Thousands of stunning Philippine women prepare to start out a chat with single Western men, so join an internet site or application right now. When the remains of the organism are analyzed provides a sign of the time elapsed since its fatality, the proportion of carbon-14 left. This includes examination of a refined piece of a material to figure out the thickness of “track” markings left in it by the spontaneous fission of uranium-238 contaminations. The uranium material of the sample has to be understood, but that can be determined by positioning a plastic movie over the sleek slice of the product, and also bombarding it with slow neutrons. Older materials can be dated using zircon, apatite, titanite, epidote as well as garnet which have a variable quantity of uranium web content. In time, ionizing radiation is taken in by mineral grains in sediments and also historical products such as quartz and potassium feldspar.

  2. You can do this by facing the person and grinning as well as nodding as they speak. When on a day, you’ll wish to see to it you have ideas of points to speak concerning and concerns to ask the various other person. This can be actually tough, particularly when we dream of exactly how things are going to go. If you’re on a day and it’s going well, do not hesitate to take points slow.” to ensure that day logistics (like when and where you’ll go) don’t hinder of making a plan. You’ll desire to try to remain off your phone as high as possible. Additionally, you’ll wish to consider where you are going when determining what to put on. Therefore, you have discovered the person you have huge crush on & assume she or he is one. Nevertheless, one of one of the most trending methods for singles to fulfill is through dating apps.

    When you make plans with a person you satisfied on a dating application, constantly inform a relied on friend or relative where you’re going. If you discover that you do not intend to proceed dating with her any longer, don’t tell her you’ll call her when you do not mean to. One more good security precaution is to use a service like ADT SoSecure, which enables you to share your area with family members as well as swiftly call for help in an emergency situation. This permits you to invest a restricted amount of time with your day till you recognize that you work as well as like hanging out with each various other! You can also decrease by stating that you’re not feeling well and wish to go home. It’s ideal to maintain it casual as you’re both still figuring out if you like each various other if you’re asking a person out that you satisfied online. Directly asking is the very best way to know for sure what your day is really feeling as well as assuming! This does not suggest you should make believe to be a person that you’re not, however it’s a good concept to attempt to present your ideal self!

    This doesn’t always mean that the person is not interested – in some cases things come up that are unanticipated as well as out of the person’s control. Usually, individuals actually enjoy chatting regarding themselves as well as things that they have an interest in! Several individuals like to get hold of a drink on their first date, but if you do determine to head to a bar, make sure to stay sober. Looking away from someone can accidentally make that individual feel like you’re not listening or interested in them. If you feel awkward or endangered, you’re in no way obligated to remain with somebody. Don’t hesitate to bail out if you feel uncomfortable at any factor during the day or perhaps before it. So see to it that whenever you find anyone or account you make it a factor to interact as long as feasible as it is the only means based on which you can learn more regarding the person. And also it does not need to take for life to specify where you have the ability to shut out your shyness and do well in any scenario where you occur to be among a lady. As clothing is a major part of thrilling somebody, so you have to clothe according to your body color as well as qpid framework to thrill your crush.

    Be conscious of body movement: Among the main distinctions in between a relationship as well as a charming partnership is physical intimacy. Being open to dating greater than someone: Though many people ultimately wish to locate a partner, it’s crucial to keep an open mind when dating. If you wish to date even more than someone at once, communicate your choice to whomever you’re dating. Numerous individuals date greater than a single person at that exact same time till they develop a close, purposeful connection with a single person. It’s a basic truth that the more experience that you have in social interactions with women – the most likely it is that you are mosting likely to feel comfy as well as not really feel as timid as you generally do. By doing this you both have some privacy during the communication. Sometimes, on the internet dating solutions can additionally be disguised with either prostitution on-line interaction. Today, online dating is just one of one of the most preferred methods to locate someone unique. Sometimes I think we simply need to focus on one point and also not whatever.

  3. Kelly claimed that she is a fan of pork however not of shrimp as she is allergic which Ali recognized. The 40-year-old actress as well as comic just recently appeared on The Kelly Clarkson Program where in the spirit of her new show Beef she ranted about the thing she could not stand the most. She was appearing on the program as her now-husband was working as protection for her performance. A handful of teams still exercise darkness puppetry in Cambodia, specifically arts and also theater companies advertising Khmer culture, such as Cambodian Living Arts, Sovanna Phum Art Organization (also referred to as Sovannaphum), Bambu Stage, as well as Bonn Phum, which is attempting to keep the performance art to life with social networks and also an annual celebration. In 2019, Lambert and also McLoughlin silently linked the knot and also exposed the information via social media on Valentine’s Day that year. By her side, McLoughlin – that she wed in 2019 – used a traditional, white T-shirt and a sharp, dark blue sports jacket.

    To match Lambert, he put on a set of medium-wash denim jeans as well as white tennis shoes embellished with a crimson Nike logo. With the top, the recipe book author sported black skinny denims combined with dark leather tennis shoes. For a bit of flair, she jazzed up the casual attire with a black, leather moto coat. After enjoying dinner with each other at Pan-Asian eatery TAO, the 39-year-old country crooner and also the former authorities policeman, 31, could be seen strolling through Central Park. And also while the country celebrity started the press excursion for her book, her partner has been seen accompanying her the whole time. It has to do with sisterhood,’ the blonde beauty – that also disclosed her spouse does a lot of the cooking in between the 2 of them – included. Social troubles. The high divorce price, high domestic physical violence price, discrimination of women, desire for self-development and also self-realization, all that makes many Asian bride-to-bes seek a husband that had actually regard their goals and values abroad.

    Trying to find Oriental mail order bride-to-bes and solitary ladies to date? Mail order sites can aid you find enduring love. One who is unable to discover time to approach anybody or not having high wage by which they can thrill the companion will truly discover websites helpful? However, seeing somebody with a smile on his/her face will certainly lighten up the mood of anybody on any kind of day, so definitely do this! You can begin seeing Eastern gems now. You can also discover matches from various other nations and backgrounds due to the fact that the app does not entirely focus on Eastern dating. If you do it, you’ll have a really great chance not just to fulfill somebody special amongst countless Asian singles but additionally to begin a healthy connection that can finish with a marriage. Those ladies, who become mail order new brides, passionately wish to meet their man amongst foreigners. Nonetheless, it is also possible to fulfill your excellent match via a cost-free dating website.

    An associate for the 44-year-old actor verified to Page Six that Hader and Wong are dating again after a previous love last fall. Dear close friends, Are you solitary and looking for a relationship? Ali Wong disclosed that she is not a big follower of obtaining Oriental food with non-Asian individuals amid records of her revived relationship with Expense Hader. Begin by sending out a friendly message introducing on your own and expressing your rate of interest in getting to know them better. I think it’s actually vital to know on your own and understand what you desire and obtain it. This is why you’ll never ever get a reason to doubt your bride’s commitment. As well as they’re essentially asking, “why is that not a sandwich?” You asked me to take you right here! Dating services are extremely preferred in the Eastern area and also global relationships are extremely usual. Asia is one of the most densely inhabited region in the world. If you’ve ever before studied the Asian better half blog site, you should recognize that many women from Asia make every effort to get PhDs. But it’s mostly simply all the inquiries, you understand.

  4. Just know that some persons are lonely and like the idea of having a pen pal as a result of they really feel that they’re having some type of relationship. So even for those who manage to create a fake profile, there may be little probability of discovering folks of your personal age group on one of those platforms. But generally, you’ll have an excellent probability of finding someone if you’re prepared to put the hassle into it. If you wish to make finding a partner a priority, personal it and make room for it in your life. If you are having trouble finding a love connection, it is all too easy to get discouraged or purchase into the destructive myths out there about courting and relationships. McLeod’s own large romance was famously the topic of a 2015 entry of the new York Times Modern Love column. I’d love to assist you discover the love of your life! On this period of digital connections and aware romance, we’re here to help you and enhance your courting journey in the brand new Year.

    Whether you are navigating the world of on-line connections or exploring traditional avenues, 2024 brings a brand new set of relationship dynamics. I favor to talk on the telephone or meet by video online.” Then, arrange a time to speak on the cellphone or video chat. Just electronic mail them about your plans to speak or meet. It is best to talk about the issues you have in frequent and ensure to ask questions to show real curiosity. Then you definitely ponder, “Does this man have other female candidates in the works and is simply preserving me on the back burner until he has exhausted his different potential dates? The again and forth becomes extended with weeks of messages despatched every day. You feel like you’ve wasted oodles of time with irritating messages because you messaged back and forth for weeks with messages despatched each day. Put a time-frame on how long you’ll go back and forth before truly assembly face-to-face. Are there some absolute belongings you will never surrender on, it doesn’t matter what? This inner critic tells us issues like, “I’ll by no means be in a relationship.” While it’s vital to study to simply accept criticism, our inside jerk is of no use to us, or anybody.

    They could also be right, however their concern about assembly in person doesn’t warrant dragging issues out for too lengthy. Are you having trouble assembly the best particular person? Whether it’s from meeting individuals IRL, dating apps, matchmakers and many others if you would like to enhance your relationship life in 2024, go on dates! However, there are specific goals and aspirations that individuals should have already reached or be actively striving for before coming into into a relationship. Besides doing glorious work, managing deadlines, being dutiful at house, you’ve got some obligations to maintain you glad additionally. I name this being an limitless pen pal. Call them on their habits or inform them, “I’ve been in a pen pal scenario before, and it’s by no means worked out. Should you don’t want to be pen pals, then you definitely need to specific your expectations about how lengthy you plan on going back and forth. Dating websites will assist you to in getting back on observe and heading to a fruitful future. So, I believe two weeks is enough time for us to get to know one another by messaging back and forth. Put aside the garments before the day of your date to evade a variety of points and oddball in the most recent attainable time.

    Several tips are mentioned below in order to help you make your date a actually amazing one. Nowadays, many programs on Tv share simple but effective dating tips for men and women. Talia Koren, a preferred relationship coach, typically took to her Instagram platform to share invaluable insights in regards to the relationship world. As soon as these typical World Wide Web relationship queries are clarified, then your further concepts show up into play. Even if you are bearded however well groomed, you’re sure to earn your self some further points. Then again, it would also be useful to you to get a date partner as well. On the other hand, you may even be pondering, “He sends daily messages, so there’s some sort of actual interest.” However, this has been happening for weeks or even months. Along with the above dating tips, a Motivated to Marry particular person needs to meet you to see whether or not there’s real curiosity in going additional with the connection. Remember your objective is to satisfy this individual and have an actual-life relationship.

  5. You are not speculated to put on a soiled T-shirt or a soiled jean anytime anyplace. She can be director and senior scientist of the Cardiovascular Nutrition Laboratory on the Jean Mayer USDA Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging, and professor of medication at Tufts University School of Medicine. Akwasi Owusu-Bempah, an assistant professor of sociology on the University of Toronto, and Anthony Morgan, a civil rights lawyer, mentioned that within the 1980s and 1990s the RCMP launched Operation Pipeline, a drug interdiction strategy used within the United States. Cl. With the event of AMS in the 1980s it grew to become doable to measure these isotopes precisely sufficient for them to be the idea of helpful courting methods, which have been primarily applied to relationship rocks. Many online dating relationships undergo due to issues as a result of their lengthy distance standing. This is essentially the most basic premise when participating in an online dating or long distance relationship. You possibly can additionally ask your date to join you in a bunch courting situation as nicely. They’re fashionable. When they measure the guy they are going to this point they could want to see the fashionable things. Too many on-line dating may seem very promising and a simple means to satisfy a accomplice, but to some they have discovered it not to be such a great experience, the place as some have had superb outcomes.

    You’ll be capable of get good responses instantly. People using online dating companies shall be given the choice to prove they are who they say they are. But Bernard knew exactly what to say to maintain her going with a script of details of his logging enterprise which included images and promises of an exquisite life together once he returned. Wikimedia Commons has media related to Shelf life. Some glues and adhesives even have a restricted storage life, and will cease working in a reliable and usable manner if their protected shelf life is exceeded. Your life story is the very last thing that you need to tell her, and is best stored for a conversation when you two finally meet face to face. Cryptocurrencies are use decentralized expertise to let customers make safe payments and store cash without the need to use their title or go through a financial institution. Make a scrap guide stuffed with blissful footage along with your faces glowing with each other. Make use of your webcam and talk to one another at any time when some issues arise in your relationship. Use soy sauce sparingly, and solely dip the edge of the topping, never the rice. If you’re particularly involved about privacy, it’s easy enough to create a free e-mail account someplace and use it solely in your on-line dating contacts.

    Just use the companies primarily based by yourself needs! Two members of her band also studied at USC. You may resolve to undergo bumble review to make it your final romance app. Another reason may embody lovers who have to be separated in distance attributable to military companies, career choices as well as work alternatives. You could also be used to Western ladies consistently making an attempt to divide the expense and even paying for the dinner themselves, nevertheless Filipino girls are usually not like that. If you enroll on a site, it is rather like window shopping if you do not have clear match standards. Just most of the girls on the planet, Russian ladies like beauties and lovely things. What make Russian beauties need to marry you? Enjoy your lengthy distance courting relationship and take advantage of out of your lives together. When making a wish at a wishing effectively, it’s customary to make a donation or go away a small token of appreciation, as a approach of expressing gratitude for the want being granted. It’s the quickest and most convenient method to search out and meet Russian ladies. This is due to the appearance of the internet the place increasingly individuals meet and find love after on-line dating.

    The very best answer is on-line courting. As a lot as it seems to be a great deal, a no price online dating net site does require a bank card quantity. A happy and wholesome person is basic to an excellent and stable relationship. Aim to foster a good and passionate online courting relationship by using the strategies talked about above. Phone calls are good when sharing experiences and glad conditions along with your lady. Remind your companion that you’re all the time there for her to return dwelling to and discuss all angst and challenges in her day by day work. What are you able to do to find your partner in Russia if you aren’t in Russia. Have a critical speak with you partner and agree that each of you will have an unique relationship with each other. Agree with one another that each of you is not going to go courting with others when you are both with each other, though far apart. 4. Be Loyal. Monogamy is a advantage which will let you have a trouble and guilt-free on-line courting relationship. Monogamy can slim the quantity of individuals you spend time with regularly, whereas an open relationship is predicated on socializing and making new connections.

  6. No matter who you are or what it is that your work is, you are going to require to support your relationship. I quite doubt these approaches are going anywhere. Besides relationship suggestions chat and recommendations by the phone you can do much more on this site. With a little care and gentleness, you can with dignity end a high-tech relationship without you, or your ex-lover, stooping to online lows. If that’s a little rich for your blood, you can sign up for texts from a “relationship guru” for $9 each month or take a 30-day email course for $149. And although consuming delicious meals, doing yoga, speaking to neuroscientists, life coaches and others who have recently been through breakups can definitely help, healing unhealthy relationship patterns can take a lifetime – not simply a weekend. They may have times of health problem or employment problem where they need to lean more difficult on their partner, but they don’t simply consider approved that they deserve to such things. Couples who can react to each other’s tension in such a way that is relaxing instead of in such a way that exacerbates it tend to be able to weather the tenser times.

    Someone who eases my stress and soothes me down. People are dealing with all examples throughout breaks up,” says Anna Belle Wood of Many Colors Counseling, who concentrates on psychiatric therapy for ladies and the LGBTQ neighborhood. “Psychological trauma is a subjective experience – significance, it is specified by you – and it is characterized by feeling overloaded and very powerless. The value of doing things together and enabling and supporting each other’s individual growth in a healthy relationship is two-fold: It allows you both to share the important things you enjoy with each other, and it gives you the space to be supportive even when something does not completely align with your own individual interests. Individual differences can asiame scam affect how people interpret and react to relationship hazards. Therefore, people date without getting into relationships all the time. Tell a friend that you’re having a difficult time not travelling your ex’s wall and profile, and ask for the psychological support you require to stop this self-flagellating habits. There’s one exception– if a mutual pal posts content to Facebook, you’ll both have the ability to see each others’ comments.

    It’s worth practicing the best words with a good friend or household member beforehand, so you’ll be prepared to articulate your wants and feelings without stumbling over them. I assist customers deal with this by bring back a sense of control over their lives, making meaning from the past, and bring back hope in the future. Worse, they just spread out ill will amongst a large social network and might create even more hard feelings, making it more tough for everybody to move on with their lives. After all, the circle of life is why all of us exist, we are born and then we grow and a number of us offer birth to new life before our lives are ended up. Why? Because you take what you require and after that use it to your situation through your own distinct viewpoint. You might right away change your relationship status to single and then begin publishing images of yourself laughing and holding hands with another individual. You may wish to begin by blocking your ex and a few of your shared good friends. It can be appealing to want to appear agreeable and prevent uneasy fight by telling a customer what you think they desire to hear or keeping your true opinion about their job.

    The loss of a close relationship, particularly relying on the information of your circumstance, can absolutely make you feel by doing this. Every couple of days I make sure they are succeeding. Sure. Life’s short, might too enjoy yourself. Or you may use the images of your old partner kissing his new squeeze to abuse yourself mentally. You may use these clues to build plots of revenge or reconciliation. They lie and slander, attempt to generate jealousy, or seek revenge in a plethora of other ways. You can enhance your outcomes with customers by utilizing strong relationship marketing principles. The ultimate results of these efforts often backfire. I don’t even understand any longer. • These accusations against me have no relationship to the truth. • No such certainty blessed our relationship with Dad. • This, it is stated, is the essential element governing the doctor-patient relationship. • Professional relationships ought to not be impacted by personal sensations. • Even at 35, Bobby appeared unable to dedicate to a romantic relationship. • The courts will not, in general, specifically enforce a common master-servant relationship. • Interest rates and federal government costs are connected, however the relationship is quite a complex one. • The relationship between public investment and private advancement is very important in thinking about how a canal would be financed. • What relationship exists in between the painting and the vision of reality that the artist has before his eyes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *