UPDATE, JUNE 7, 11:52 A.M.: 25-year-old Hollywood resident Vitaliy Krasnoperov is accused of conspiring with childhood friend Iftekhar Murtaza via online instant messages to plan and carry out the kidnapping, murder and setting ablaze of the sister and father of Murtaza's ex-girlfriend four years ago.
The first trial of Krasnoperov ended in mistrial last month, but he isn't off the hook yet. An Orange County judge has consolidated the murder trials of Krasnoperov and another man authorities have tied to the plot, Charles Anthony Murphy Jr., 25, of Mission Hills. Their trial is now scheduled to begin later this year.
The crime was horrific even by horrific Orange County standards. Sometime after 6:30 p.m. on May 21, 2007, 56-year-old Jaypraykash
Dhanak, who worked with his wife
Leela Dhanak in Irvine, was in his Anaheim Hills home alone after leaving work and agreeing to
meet her there later. But someone entered the home and forcibly
restrained Dhanak before beating and repeatedly stabbing him. He was
left in a bathroom while his attackers awaited the arrival of 54-year-old Leela and her daughter Karishma Dhanak, 20.
After being dropped off at the home around 10:30 p.m., the daughter was forcibly detained. When the mother arrived about 15 minutes
later, she was immediately attacked and stabbed in the stomach. The home was then doused in gasoline and set ablaze as the attackers tried to move the father, mother and daughter into a van
However, a witness approached the home because the fire had spread by then. The attackers only managed to drive off with Jaypraykash and
Karishma Dhanak in the van. Leela Dhanak was left unconscious on her
The witness managed to flag down a passing patrol car, and an
officer attended to the woman while the home was engulfed in flames and
The next day, the bodies of Jaypraykash and Karishma Dhanak were found set ablaze on a bike trail at Mason Regional Park
in Irvine. Leela spent a month in the hospital as a result of her wounds, including about three weeks in a coma.
Anaheim Police detectives investigating the case quickly indentified Murtaza, the former boyfriend of Karishma's then-18-year-old sister Shayona Dhanak, as a
suspect. Then a UC Irvine freshman who resided in the campus dorms, Shayona had ended a nearly three-year relationship with Murtaza in March of '07. The 25-year-old Van Nuys man is alleged to have become angry not with her over the
breakup but her parents. The Dhanaks, practicing Hindus, did not approve
of their daughter dating Murtaza, a
He allegedly fled to Phoenix, Arizona, where he was arrested on May
25, 2007, attempting to board a plane to India with a one-way ticket and $11,000 in cash. He was later extradited back to Orange County and the subsequent investigation led the arrests of Krasnoperov and Murphy.
The evidence against the trio–well, at least the evidence released to the public via the Orange County District Attorney's office–includes IM's they have sent to one another via AOL. These include Murtaza allegedly telling Krasnoperov he wanted to bump off the elder Dhanaks and burn down their house. Krasnoperov is accused of enlisting Murphy, who Murtaza is said to have offered $30,000 and arranged to meet the day Jayprakash Dhanak was attacked by intruders.
Krasnoperov's first trial ended with a hung jury in May, but Superior Court Judge Thomas M. Goethals agreed on Monday to rejoin the trials of Krasnoperov and Murphy, which had previously been severed for various legal reasons. Currently being held without bail, the pair could get life in prison without the possibility of parole if convicted.
Murtaza, who is also being held without bail, could get a death sentence if convicted after his trial, which is scheduled to begin next year.
ORIGINAL POST, MARCH 4, 2010, 10:57 A.M.: Opening statements begin today in the trial of a Garden Grove man accused of choking his 71-year-old mother to death, while District Attorney Tony Rackauckas has already announced he will seek the death penalty for a Van Nuys man accused of murdering his ex-girlfriend's father and sister, trying to murder her mother and setting all three bodies on fire. A pre-trial hearing is scheduled Friday in that case.
Iftekhar Murtaza, 25, is charged with two
felony counts of special circumstances murder, one felony count of
attempted murder, and one felony count of conspiracy to commit murder.
He faces sentencing enhancements for multiple murders, murder during
the commission of a burglary, murder during the commission of
kidnapping, and murder for financial gain. He is being held
Co-defendants Vitaliy Krasnoperov, 24, of Hollywood, and Charles Anthony
Murphy, Jr., 25, of Mission Hills, face the same charges and sentencing enhancements as Murtaza, although Murphy is tagged with an additional enhancement for murder for
financial gain. They could get life
in prison without the possibility of parole if convicted. They are also being held without bail and scheduled to attend Friday's pre-trial
hearing with Murtaza.
Here's how the case breaks down, according to the Orange County District Attorney's Office:
On March 29, 2007, 18-year-old Shayona Dhanak, a UC Irvine fresman who lived in the campus dorms, ended a two-year dating
relationship with Murtaza. Her family in Anaheim Hills disapproved of the relationship
partly because they were practicing Hindus and Murtaza was a
Murtaza allegedly became angry over the
break-up and blamed Dhanak's parents. He is accused of contacting his friend
Krasnoperov online and telling him in an AOL Instant Messenger conversation that he wanted to kill his ex-girlfriend's father, Jaypraykash Dhanak, 56, and mother, Leela Dhanak, 54.
Ways to murder the parents, including burning their house down or using
a hit man, were allegedly discussed via IM. Krasnoperov is accused of offering to contact someone whom
he knew "used to do this type of work.”
In an April 26, 2007, IM conversation, Krasnoperov allegedly arranged a meeting where the Dhanak family murders would be negotiated. Murtaza supposedly arranged to get photographs of the family by sending Shayona Dhanak an IM asking for a shot from her recent family trip to India.
In the early afternoon of May 21, 2007, IM conversation with his childhood friend Murphy, Murtaza is accused of offering him $30,000 "for a job” and arranging a face-to-face meeting that day to discuss
the details of the murders to be carried out that night.
Sometime after 6:30 p.m. that same day, Jaypraykash Dhanak, who worked with his wife
in Irvine, was in his house alone after leaving work and agreeing to
meet Leela there later. Someone entered the home and forcibly restrained the father before beating and repeatedly stabbing him.
The man was left in the bathroom while his attackers awaited the arrival of the mother and daughter, according to prosecutors.
Karishma Dhanak, Shayona's 20-year-old sister, was dropped off at the Anaheim Hills home around 10:30 p.m. She was forcibly detained, and when Leela Dhanak arrived about 15 minutes later, she was immediately attacked and stabbed in the stomach.
The home was then doused in gasoline and set ablaze as their attackers tried to move the father, mother and daughter into a van parked outside. But a witness who approached the home because of the fire disrupted their plans, as they drove off with Jaypraykash and Karishma Dhanak but had to leave Leela Dhanak unconscious on her neighbor's lawn.
The witness managed to flag down a passing patrol car, and an officer attended to the woman while the home was engulfed in flames and largely destroyed.
The mother wound up spending a month in the hospital as a result of her wounds, including about three weeks in a coma.
The bodies of Jaypraykash and Karishma Dhanak were found set ablaze on a bike trail at Mason Regional Park
in Irvine the next day.
Anaheim Police detectives investigating the case indentified Murtaza as a suspect. He allegedly fled to Phoenix, Arizona, and was arrested on May 25, 2007, attempting to board a plane to India with a one-way
plane ticket and $11,000 in cash.
He was later extradited back to Orange County and the subsequent investigation led the arrests of Krasnoperov and Murphy.
In the Garden Grove case, 31-year-old Richard
Lam Nguyen is accused of strangling
and murdering his mother, Nuong Nguyen, after becoming angry when she said she disapproved of
his pharmacy studies and wanted him to become a physician.
The son, who is charged with one felony count of
murder, is a graduate of the University of California, Irvine
with a bachelor's in biology. At the time of the murder, he
was a first-year student at Ross University in Dominica, located in the
Caribbean, studying to be a pharmacist.
Late on the night of Dec. 20, 2008, he was in the Garden Grove home he shared with his mother when, prosecutors allege, she indicated she did
not support his desire to become a pharmacist. He allegedly became so enraged that he strangled the elderly, 5-foot-tall, 80-pound woman with his bare hands in the
Police earlier said Richard Nguyen then wandered the street outside for awhile before sleeping in his car parked outside the home. Ar around
10:30 a.m. the next morning, he called police to report that
his mother had passed away. An autopsy later confirmed she'd been strangled.