Today on the High-Speed Rail Seesaw...

Are the current plans for a $40-billion high-speed train meant to connect Fresno and San Francisco with Los Angeles, Anaheim and San Diego brilliant or reckless? Everytime you start to form an opinion, something comes the other way down the tracks. 

Take, for example, the past 24 hours:

  • A poll released yesterday afternoon says that 76% of Californians support the high-speed rail line.

  • But that poll was conducted as part of a public relations campaign on behalf of the California High Speed Rail Authority. It didn't highlight the project's potential downsides and possibly flawed ridership projections, but it did highlight 11 potential benefits, including the claim that the train would be cheaper than other forms of transportation. The Sacramento Bee's Dan Walters dismissed the poll as "spin."

  • BUT in a terse comment on the Walters' column, high-speed rail official Jeff Barker pointed out examples from around the world showing that bullet trains are nearly always less expensive than airplane travel.

  • However, high-speed rail advocate and Orange County ex-pat Robert Cruickshank excoriated Orange and Ward for using allegedly discredited information in their discrediting of high speed rail. Earlier, he claimed that Voice of OC reporter Tracy Wood was a hack for the anti-train cause.

Getting motion sickness here. Can't we all just agree that it'd be better if we had teleporters?


All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >