Disgusting Buena Park Liquor Store Robbers Claim Judge Stole Justice

Neil Deontrai Duffey and William Deshawn Cartlidge committed a brutal, senseless Buena Park liquor store robbery in August 2006, but insist that Orange County's criminal justice system robbed them of a fair trial.

Duffey shot the store clerk in the head with a handgun, shot a customer entering the store three times and fled carrying stolen California Lottery tickets a cash register containing only $200.

The bandits also grabbed the customer's wallet and left the two victims seriously wounded.

Two days later, police arrested Duffey and Cartlidge.

The thieve's relatives tried to provide an fool-proof alibi but surveillance video and forensic testing wrecked the plan.

A 2010 Orange County jury convicted both men--it helped that Cartlidge squealed during a post-crime interrogation--and Superior Court Judge James A. Stotler sentenced them to prison.

The men appealed, claiming that a prosecutor solicited improper law enforcement testimony and failed to prove they intended to rob the customer. Because they wanted to be able to blame the other, they also objected that Stotler refused to conduct separate trials.

Writing for the California Court of Appeal based in Santa Ana, Justice Richard Aronson considered and dismissed each of the defendant's complaints as worthless.

Disgusting Buena Park Liquor Store Robbers Claim Judge Stole Justice

Upshot: Duffey, 24, will continue to serve his 64 years to life sentence and Cartlidge, 25, will continue to serve his 14 years to life punishment. 

Both men now call home a place where there are no lottery tickets or cash registers: Calipatria State Prison.

Their victims suffered significant, scarring wounds but survived.

Follow OC Weekly on Twitter @ocweekly or on Facebook


All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >