Reeve, dog namer
Reeve, dog namer

[UPDATED with Plagiarism Allegations:] Bill O'Reilly Pins the Head of SJC Councilman Derek Reeve for Naming Family Dog Muhammad

UPDATE, SEPT. 27, 10:17 A.M.: Before Bill O'Reilly labeled Derek Reeve a "pinhead" for naming one of his dogs after the Islamic prophet Muhammad, the San Juan Capistrano city councilman was being called out for plagiarism.

Editors say Reeve was questioned about a passage in one column that was apparently lifted word-for-word from another publication without attribution. The councilman reportedly explained it away as human error, but his defense and Patch work stopped about a month ago when more examples of plagiarism were found in dozens of his writings.

Reports San Juan Capistrano Patch editor Jenna Chandler, "as much as two-thirds of Reeve's essays were a patchwork of paragraphs identical to material written by newspaper columnists and reporters for such publications as The Oregonian and The Hill."

Chandler's piece includes multiple examples of Reeve passing off the prose of others as his own. It's bad enough that a city councilman is plagiarizing, but he's also a lawyer who lectures at local colleges. One, as Chandler points out, is Concordia University, whose employee handbook states: "Plagiarism may be unintentional or intentional. Both are serious academic violations."

A Concordia spokeswoman did not return Patch's messages seeking comment.

ORIGINAL POST, SEPT. 23, 1:09 P.M.: Time was, you'd have to wait for Keith Obermann to label a San Juan Capistrano city councilman who named his dog after the prophet Muhammad the World's Worst Person. But Obermann is now on some channel you can't find without a program guide, so it is up to another flaming liberal chatter to tar Councilman Derek Reeve as a "pinhead."

Uh, check that: it was Obermann's arch rival, Bill O'Reilly.

Voting on a local dog park at the Sept. 6 City Council meeting, Reeve let it slip that his pooches are named America and Muhammad. That prompted his colleagues to seek "decorum" at future council meetings--and the Greater Los Angeles office of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) in Anaheim to later seek an apology.

But Reeve has been unrepentant, explaining that he did not mean to offend Muslims but to teach his children about free speech, noting that in some parts of the Islamic world he could be put to death for naming his dog after the religion's prophet.

Besides, the Pattersons across the street already took that name Saxnōt for their cockapoo.

Well, the whole dust-up prompted Papa Bear to put Reeve in the first category during The O'Reilly Factor's "Pinheads & Patriots" segment on Fox News Thursday. "Why offend Muslims if you don't have to?" O'Reilly reasoned. "You want to teach your kids about intolerance, there are plenty of other ways to do it."

Here's the video:

Reacting via his Facebook page, Reeve wrote, ""I'm a pin head, lol."



All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >