Sheriff Hutchens: Badgered
Sheriff Hutchens: Badgered
Keith May

[Moxley Confidential] OC Media Asked to Ignore Still-Emerging Dirt on Mike Carona's PSR Mess

Badge Boys, Badge Boys
OC media asked to ignore still-emerging dirt on Carona’s PSR mess at the sheriff’s department

Thinking I’d hear details about needed Orange County Sheriff’s Department (OCSD) reforms, I was prepared to write a positive review of Sheriff Sandra Hutchens’ latest press conference dealing with the damn real badges her predecessor, the FBI-indicted Mike Carona, slipped to the folks he partied with: two wealthy Dana Point resort builders who hosted his fund-raising events; his convicted-felon martial-arts instructor; the owner of his favorite South Coast Plaza-area restaurant; a Las Vegas businessman who associates with organized-crime thugs; numerous political hacks; his political consultant; his pollster; two local billionaires caught in federal corruption probes; a Newport Beach man linked to European mafia and stolen high-end sports cars in LA; a Nevada casino boss; an Anaheim liquor-store king caught attempting to bribe a federal official; various campaign contributors; a man who testified for the gang-rapist son of an assistant sheriff; and the husband of Susan Atkins, the infamous, incarcerated Charles Manson family member convicted of murdering actress Sharon Tate and her unborn baby in 1969.

But upon arrival, it became clear that Hutchens, a retired LA County Sheriff’s chief appointed OC’s top cop by the Board of Supervisors three months ago, had summoned the press corps to her department’s Tustin training facility on Aug. 25 under murky pretenses. She didn’t want to make news. She wanted to remind us of something we already knew: Despite Carona’s tainted influence, hundreds of fine men and women routinely volunteer their specialties to the OCSD’s Professional Service Responders (PSR) program without compensation.

“We couldn’t function without them,” a sincere Hutchens said while standing in front of several high-ranking sheriff’s officials who’d backed Carona long after it was clear he was a pathetic character from the pages of a seedy dime novel.

Okay, I get it. The program, like the OCSD itself, now needs a PR boost. To drive the point home, Hutchens paraded before us four outstanding PSR guys—George Ridley, Tim Reynolds, Fred Arnow and Dr. Kenneth Cheng. Each said his contributions had everything to do with public service, not grabbing badges (which have been recalled).

But then Hutchens gave the microphone to Community Services Division Captain Brian Wilkerson, who oversees deputized reserves as well as the PSR unit. He’s also apparently in change of the Department of Messenger-Blaming: He proceeded to scold the media for informing the public about PSR abuses. Incredibly, he didn’t mention the real villains: Carona and the, well, colorful characters he made PSRs, some of whom remain active.

“Truthfully, um, I think they [PSR volunteers] have been somewhat misrepresented, uh, in the press,” Wilkerson intoned, grabbing the podium firmly with both hands, “by, uh, constantly focusing on the negative that was a few years ago when the program started up for some of the people that [sic] were involved in it and the vast majority of the people who participate in this program do an outstanding service for the department and the citizens of Orange County. And quite honestly, that’s what I’d like y’all to report on, is what they’re doing today, because the allegations of what happened in the past administration truly is old news.”

Uh, Brian, I don’t remember you challenging Carona when he was in power—we’re not dealing with ancient history. It was this summer when the man formerly in charge of PSR operations, Assistant Sheriff Don Haidl, confessed to FBI agents that badges had been sold during Carona’s reign. Furthermore, PSR members linked to that scandal remain in your program. And, as LA Times reporters Christine Hanley and Stuart Pfeifer recently discovered, a whopping 42 members of the PSR claimed they lost their badges after being asked to turn them in.

After the press conference, I asked about the contributions of still-active Carona PSR millionaire cronies such as real-estate developer Michael Harrah and the father-son team of Hadi and Paul Makarechian, major GOP contributors and owners of the St. Regis Resort in Dana Point.

For the past three years, it’s been Lieutenant Tom Slayton’s task to clean up the PSR program. He’s done a fine job, and he wasn’t defensive about my inquiry. Slayton gave me in-depth answers about Harrah (0 hours of service since 2005); Paul Makarechian (never gave a minute to the program); and his father, Hadi (468 hours since 2005 by donating use of his private jet).

Does inactivity raise questions about a member’s intentions?

“I don’t see a downside to keeping a lot of backups,” Slayton told me. “Now that the badge issue is gone, the controversy should be gone. These people are here to volunteer their time, nothing more.”

A still-whining Representative Loretta Sanchez, a backer of Hillary Clinton’s losing presidential campaign, told before the Denver convention that Clinton supporters have “encountered a disconnect” with Barack Obama’s staff.

Besides her choice losing, what pissed off the Santa Ana Democrat on the eve of Obama’s historic moment?

Obama announced his vice presidential selection in a 3 a.m. text message—a move Sanchez said angered Clinton backers because it might have mocked her controversial "who do you want answering the White House phone at 3 a.m.?" television ad during the primary.

If the theory is true, that’s funny. But not to Sanchez. She retaliated by noting that some Democrats are “so unhappy” with such perceived slights that they plan to abandon serious policy concerns and vote for John McCain.

Bob Dornan, once the conscience of Orange County conservatism, must be rolling over in his grave: A local Republican recently praised Jimmy Carter’s White House work. Can you believe it? What did you say? Dornan’s still alive? Oh, okay. I was told Dana Rohrabacher buried him in the 2004 primary election.

Anyhow, Representative Darrell Issa, the Republican congressman who used to represent a sliver of South OC (since gerrymandered over to the wrong side of the San Diego and Riverside county lines), essentially declared the Democratic president a genius at an Aug. 21 Washington, D.C., press conference on high gas prices.

“Jimmy Carter warned us [three decades ago] that we had to get energy self-sufficient,” Issa told reporters. “And I’ll speak on behalf of President Jimmy Carter for a moment. He said we had to dedicate ourselves toward energy self-sufficiency. . . . The real damage to our economy is not heeding what Jimmy Carter told us before many of you in the audience were even born.”

Can you imagine the stoning planned by local Republican Party boss Scott Baugh?

But at the same press conference, Representative Ed Royce balanced Issa’s gesture by shamelessly regurgitating his party’s PR talking points. Royce suggested that Democrats are responsible for making Texas and Middle East oilmen even richer—no mention of the snorting Texan, George W. Bush. The Fullerton Republican slyly noted his “concern” that “since the Democratic leadership took control of the House, the price of gas has roughly doubled.”

Guess what, Eddie: Since Nancy Pelosi and the Dems took over the House, Michael Phelps won eight gold Olympic medals.

In a fascinating Aug. 10 New York Times article (“A Tall, Cool Drink of Sewage?”) about Orange County’s efforts to recycle toilet waste into tap water, reporter Elizabeth Royte interviewed a UC Santa Cruz associate professor about the critical need to “abridge” reality by marketing campaigns.

The key: citizen memory loss.

“We abridge history all the time,” Brent Haddad told Royte. “Think of the restaurant fork that was in the mouth of someone with a contagious disease, [or] the pillow that was underneath people doing private, adult things in a hotel bedroom.”

I’d rather not.


All-access pass to the top stories, events and offers around town.

  • Top Stories


All-access pass to top stories, events and offers around town.

Sign Up >

No Thanks!

Remind Me Later >