1. "These Arms": Hard to tell whether it's the sweeping piano intro or the unexpected ultra-sentimental sincerity that washes over listeners, but one thing is clear: "These Arms" makes the ladies (and guys too, actually) swoon. One friend even said it makes him feel "fuzzy." Fuzzy's a good thing.
2. "Cold December": Once witnessed a pack of girls gather quietly beneath a wall of television screens when the video for this song—his first single—was being played in Nordstrom. With his Ray-Bans, pea coat and politely disheveled hair, it's understandable: Costa totally looks like Bob Dylan in it.
3."Miss Magnolia": During a performance in Arizona, a misplaced harmonica leads to a lighthearted sing-along jamboree—complete with shakers, handclaps and smiles. Lots of smiles. It's one of his best.
4. "Sweet Thursday": Costa gets bonus street-cred points here for the numerous Steinbeck references (see also: "Ballad of Miss Kate").
5. "Sunshine": With its hook-y "Brown-Eyed Girl" sha-la-la-las, simple-but-not-really lyrics and just overall one-of-us general appeal, "Sunshine" is a great choice for the second single—people, please pay attention this time.
Get the Music Newsletter
Keep your thumb on the local music scene each week with music news, trends, artist interviews and concert listings. We'll also send you special ticket offers and music deals.