John R. Leonetti
Horror 95 October 3, 2014
The films are stylistically similar but are only narratively related by a common prop: a haunted, Lady Elaine–esque doll. That goofy-looking toy is one of several formerly inanimate objects that pick on expecting couple John and Mia (Ward Horton and Annabelle Wallis) after Satanic cultists attack their idyllic suburban home. Even after moving to a new apartment, Mia fears for her unborn daughter's life when she's summarily assaulted by everything from a creaky rocking chair to a black baby carriage.
Annabelle's percussive series of jump-scares rarely feels monotonous thanks to helmer John R. Leonetti's assured direction. With a lot of help from cinematographer John Kniest, Leonetti (Mortal Kombat: Annihilation, The Butterfly Effect 2) admirably sets up terror that the film usually doesn't fully pay off, like an early jolt when Manson Family–style fanatics are shown massacring John and Mia's next-door neighbors through adjoining bedroom windows. Both killers and victims over-act abysmally, but Leonetti's suspenseful choreography and Kniest's low-contrast, motion-smoothed digital photography make the scene feel like a voyeur's nightmare. Annabelle's similarly inelegant, but surprisingly unnerving.