Like Martin Scorsese, who cast Blanchett as Hepburn, Soderbergh was astute enough to see Blanchett's diva potential, but she may be living in the wrong movie era. Set her down among the emaciated twigs who pass for starlets these days, and she's enormous in every sense. She has the charisma, the unorthodox beauty and the dramatic intensity of a 1940s superstar. She doesn't "disappear" into her roles—that would be mere proficiency—but puts her own stamp on them, and she's way too versatile to be pegged as a character actor. That wide, mobile mouth promises infinite possibilities of strength and vulnerability, and there's a goofy screwball comedian in her who doesn't get used nearly enough. Yet more often than not, she finds herself in subordinate roles that may help sell a movie, but sell her capabilities short. In Alejandro Gonzlez Irritu's Babel, as Brad Pitt's troubled wife, who's shot by a sniper in the first few minutes, Blanchett has little to do but writhe filthy and half-naked on the dirt floor of a Moroccan hovel. Blanchett reveled in the intensity of working with Irritu, and she shrugs off charges that the director bit off more than he could chew with a huge ensemble and a global reach. "Things that are different always come in for criticism," she says matter-of-factly. "You just have to brace yourself for it." She's less thick-skinned about the mixed reviews for Richard Eyre's Notes on a Scandal, an atonal melodrama in which Blanchett plays a disoriented high school art teacher who allows herself to be drawn into an affair with a 15-year-old pupil, then further entangles herself with a manipulative closet lesbian played by Judi Dench. It's true that Blanchett and Dench's overwrought dialectic wrings whatever fun there is to be had from a movie that feels like a cheap parody of a Muriel Spark novel. But when I tell her that Notes on a Scandal has already raised hackles among women who found both characters pathetic and demeaning, Blanchett bridles. She doesn't lose her cool, but she's clearly not amused, and shoots back with a prickly "I think its purpose is to raise everyone's hackles. It's a very spiky, difficult subject, about two women who are deeply, deeply lonely, and utterly isolated in their loneliness. It's always disappointing when you make something and people take it on the shallowest level."
I've spent three days looking at Blanchett's movies, and there's not a shallow performance among them. Unless, oddly enough, you count the one that won her the Oscar, in which she gives a broad, manneristic imitation rather than an interpretation of Hepburn. That's hardly her fault, since Scorsese hasn't excelled at creating female roles. "My knees were sweating when Scorsese asked me to do it," she admits. "I relished the chance of working with him, because female roles in his films, let's face it, don't come up very often. When I had the first conversation with him, I don't think I really registered what he'd asked me to do. I just said, yes, of course, I'd love to. And then I got off the phone and said to my husband, 'He's just asked me to play Katharine Hepburn in a film about Howard Hughes.' And he went, 'Oh my God, that's gonna be tough, playing Hepburn in color.' And I said, 'Oh shit.' I sat down in a chair and stared at the floor for a long time. And as it sank in, I thought, you just get on with it."
Getting on with it seems to be Blanchett's mantra. She brings a no-nonsense Aussie practicality to her fame and her work, and I get the sense she's not the sort of person you'd ask about her personal life without risking rebuff. When I do ask if she comes from an acting family, she twinkles away, then mischievously offers the opaque reply, "Everyone comes from an acting family." There were no professional actors in her family. Her father, a Texan of French descent who died of a heart attack when she was 10, was in advertising, her older brother is a computer programmer, and her younger sister is a former set designer who's moved into architecture. What Blanchett calls her "playful endeavors" as a child were very much supported by her mother, a Melbourne teacher, and she did a lot of acting and directing in high school. But when her art teacher urged her to go to drama school, she was horrified. "I had a very strong sense that I must be able to look after myself." At university, she was interested in the political side of economics, but had no facility for the number-crunching side of it, and after taking a year off to travel, she entered drama school in Sydney. "For some people, it dampens their instincts, but I found it utterly galvanizing and focusing to be at drama school."
Blanchett's first film role was in Bruce Beresford's Paradise Road, in which she played an Australian nurse captured by the Japanese in World War II, and she was charming opposite Ralph Fiennes in Oscar and Lucinda. But since then, as with The Good German, more often than not she's either the best thing about the movie (she brought life to the incoherent 2005 Australian drama Little Fish, in which she played a former junkie struggling to stay clean) or way too good for the role (as the wife of John Cusack's flight controller in Mike Newell's Pushing Tin) or terrific but too little seen (as a bored American heiress in The Talented Mr. Ripley). In the Lord of the Rings trilogy, she wasn't much more than a pair of pointy ears. Given her ubiquity, it's strange that Blanchett still hovers on the periphery of the A-list. Of her Australian compatriots—Nicole Kidman, Naomi Watts, the up-and-coming Abbie Cornish—only Toni Collette shows anything approaching her range. And Collette lacks the charismatic presence, the habit of filling up any screen that frames her, that surely landed Blanchett her only lead role to date, as the Queen of England in Shekhar Kapur's 1998 movie Elizabeth, for which she received a Best Actress nomination. At the tender age of 29 and without apparent strain, she brought off the difficult task of transforming Elizabeth from a lusty, naive girl into a seasoned politician canny enough to reinvent herself as a virgin, married only to England. "And no authority," Blanchett says when I bring up the film, adding merrily, "A bit like working in the film industry, isn't it?"
Blanchett has never positioned herself as a fixture on the Hollywood scene. She and her husband, the Australian playwright and screenwriter Andrew Upton, and their two young sons have lived all over in recent years, though mainly in London and Brighton, on England's south coast, an outpost for many expatriate Australians. She comes across as ambivalent about Hollywood stardom. "I think it depends who you're speaking to as to how bright my name shines," she says. "I always feel as though I have one toe in the industry, and that's the way I like it." Enough to have moved back to Sydney recently, where she and Upton signed a three-year renewable contract as joint artistic directors of the Sydney Theatre Company. "I'm Australian in every sense of the word," she says. "My landscape references, all my internal photographic memories, are from Australia. It's the culture I most want to give back to." Her contract leaves her three months a year to do other things, and Blanchett shows no sign of neglecting her film career. Given the chance, she'd work with some seriously dead directors (Kurosawa, Kieslowski) and some live ones she's already worked with—Scorsese, Soderbergh, Jarmusch and Sam Raimi, with whom she did The Gift.
This year, she resumes her role as Queen Elizabeth I in Kapur's sequel The Golden Age, which examines the monarch's relationship with the explorer Sir Walter Raleigh. She will be one of seven actors representing some aspect of the life and work of Bob Dylan in Todd Haynes' I'm Not There. And in 2008, she'll play a young woman in a relationship with an older man who's aging backward in David Fincher's adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. Pretty good going for someone who insists that she's "never been on the road to anywhere in particular." But those of us who hanker for the golden days when movie stars were shaped by their personalities, not by publicists, would love to see her star shine brighter yet.
Get the Film & TV Newsletter
Stay up to date on the best new movies with our critics' latest reviews, interviews and trailers for the films coming to a theater near you each week.