Every year, our Mexican In Chief gives bourbon bottles to his favorite bars after his annual sojourn to Kentucky. And every year, he reserves his best find for Chapter One: the modern local. On the menu this year? Barton's Chocolate Bourbon Ball Liqueur—think Bailey's, but better, with a base of Very Old Barton's, a bourbon available only in the Midwest that battles with Evan Williams for the crown of prince of the lower-end bourbons. Chapter One only has one bottle of Barton's cream liqueur, and there's no guarantee you'll get a sip, so ask nicely and console yourself with the rest of the awesome cocktails there, if you miss out.