Do Mexicans Believe in the Right to Bear Arms?

[¡Ask a Mexican!] And is it true they can only buy guns in one store?

DEAR MEXICAN: As with many Americans, I've heard about the "Fast and Furious" scandal in which our own Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) was shown to be guilty of supplying guns that ended up in the hands of the drug cartels. Now, if I say any more, I might be talking about facts I don't know, and I would probably only be spouting off what I heard on the news. I also recently saw a report about the violence in Mexico, and it mentioned something I was unaware of: There is only one place in all of Mexico for a citizen to purchase a firearm. However, we know the cartels in Ciudad Juarez (and other parts of Mexico) are heavily armed. Of course, there is always the larger world market the cartels could use to find their firepower. But just across the border in the U.S., there are hundreds of gun stores, in addition to an ATF that is apparently willing to supply guns to them.

Now, I'm not much of a gun proponent or opponent. I don't think firearms (in and of themselves) are the cause of or solution to most of our societal problems. However, I do know that firepower makes cartels powerful, and the drug violence coming out of Mexico is hard to ignore. In light of the fact that Mexicans can only legally obtain one gun, purchased from one location (if they meet all the requirements), what are the statistics for gun ownership in Mexico? How does the Mexican culture differ when it comes to the average citizen and their view of safety and their right to protect themselves? There are obviously differing opinions in the USA about gun ownership, rights and control. Similarly, I would expect Mexicans have different views and opinions among one another regarding firearms.

But really, my main question is: One gun store? In all of Mexico? One gun store? Meanwhile, Juarez is awash with guns and blood. . . .

Curious Jorge

 

DEAR POCHO: Before I get to your pregunta, a quick comment on Fast and Furious: while I'm no fan of the Obama administration, isn't it so gabacho for Obama critics to only care about the smuggling of guns into Mexico, which causes untold misery to so many, when they can embarrass him with it? Refry this, gabachos: Mexicans have been buying guns in the States and sneaking them into Mexico since the days of the Magón brothers (my favorite smuggling story: a man I knew once wrapped yarn around a ball of bullets and had his wife take it onto a plane; she ended up knitting a sweater with it. This was in the days antes de 9/11, of course). And Ronald Reagan sold arms to the Contras—or was that okay, because he was fighting supposed commies?

Back to the question: Mexicans love their guns as much as they love salsa, and while the Mexican government highly regulates sales of guns (although nowhere near as stringent as the one-shop rule you heard), gun violence is still high. A July 2012 post by The Guardian cited stats that showed Mexico's gun-ownership rate was 15 per 100 people (42nd highest country in the world), which paled en comparación to the U.S.'s astounding número uno rate of 88.8 per 100. The homicide by firearm rate per 100,000 goes to the Mexicans: whereas in the U.S., the figure was 2.97, the Mexico cifra was 9.97. As for the percentage of homicides due to firearms? 54.9 percent for Mexis, Americans clock in at 60 percent—not much difference. One huge caveat, though: The report was compiled based on stats from 2007, far before the narcowars engulfed most of the country. With a police force as ineffectual as the GOP's Latino outreach program, the right to bear arms for Mexicans isn't just some high-falutin' constitutional ideal—it's usually the only way to ensure you stay alive.

 
My Voice Nation Help
8 comments
Justin_Khase
Justin_Khase

If they did America wouldn't have immigration problems at the south border.

jamestrafficant
jamestrafficant

@STOPTHERECONQUISTA stop hating on immigrants, they're not destroying the economy, it's the republicans and democrats who you continue to vote into office, who spend money and tax business. Juan nor your kid is going to have a job, even after they get out of college, because jobs are going to states with lower taxes. So instead of complaining about immigrants, start looking at the people you elect, how fiscally conservative are they? 

STOPTHERECONQUISTA
STOPTHERECONQUISTA

"Dad, we are middle class Americans...right"

"Yes son"
"Well, why does my friend Juan who's here illegally with his parents get Pell Grants and Cal Grants for college, while I have to have $50,000 in student loans?"
"Well Son, the Democrats hate Americans"

STOPTHERECONQUISTA
STOPTHERECONQUISTA

@jamestrafficant @STOPTHERECONQUISTA I absolutely agree both parties are supporting the 1% and that is the prime issue....however,  I also believe part of their plan is to support illegal immigration and that undermines our middle class lives. it's is anti-illegal immigration by the way.

skmind
skmind

@STOPTHERECONQUISTA "Well dad, isn't that naive and border line racist?"

"No son, that is Republican.  You see, Republicans can say things and assume they are true.  Because Jesus, 9/11 and Obama is black, son!"

STOPTHERECONQUISTA
STOPTHERECONQUISTA

@skmind @STOPTHERECONQUISTA No...you are wrong. I know for a fact I've got $50,000 in parent student loans, and the dreamers will get pell grants and cal grants....and enter their careers with far less debt. I don't think it is right that my taxes provide free college for the dreamers while my own children are smothered in debt. My taxes should go to my children.

 
Loading...