I think you might be too harsh on this one. H&G was the best story this weekend. I dare you to go see Movie 43 and tell me H&G was bad. H&G didn't pretend to be something it wasn't, that's why it succeeded. Yea it was revisionist for the adult versions of H&G but it got their childhood story right. It also pointed out that there are good witches. If you keep your expectations level you will have a good time. It's not as bad as reviewers say.