Bare, Ruined Choirs

The historic buildings in the way of One Broadway Plaza were doomed
long before the vote on Measure A

Five feet, nine inches tall, in armpit hair, a Panama-style hat advertising Corona beer, and a vest made to resemble a serape, the often-shirtless Jose Teo Ochoa would not be your first choice for spokesman. But if you stand in the back yard outside 1103 N. Broadway and holler long enough, he's usually the guy who comes downstairs to say a few words on anything from police brutality to the weather.

Ochoa is the de facto public-information officer for the six men and three women—all previously homeless—who spent several months living in Santa Ana's historic Tudor Revival-style 1914 McNeill-Basler house. But you don't have to worry; they're homeless again, rousted by Santa Ana police on March 8. The house and its neighbor, the 1928 Yale Apartments at 1007 N. Broadway, are vacant, boarded up and in limbo. Again.

But that doesn't matter; nor does it matter that both buildings are owned by Orange County real-estate mogul Mike Harrah (also OC Weekly's landlord)—or that they sit directly in the footprint of Harrah's 37-story One Broadway Plaza (OBP) office building. You might have even been among the 18.5 percent of Santa Ana voters who turned out in the April 5 Measure A referendum on letting Harrah build OBP. After Harrah's "Yes on Measure A" committee spent roughly $370 thousand pushing its shiny product, 56.6 percent of that 18.5 percent said yea. Maybe fans of the McNeill-Basler house and the Yale Apartments should have seen this coming.

No one knows what to do with them; no one has the vision, the plan or the commitment—i.e., money—to revitalize them or their street, a once-choice residential neighborhood, so that it will do anything but make money: not the city, not Harrah (who owns much of it), not preservationists, not the police, not even the homeless people who lived there. Santa Ana has little of the finesse you see in cities such as Pasadena, where historic residential neighborhoods throughout have been painstakingly preserved whole—and kept apart from retail and commercial districts. Santa Ana has created no such plan for its history, nor has one evolved. Its key historic residential neighborhoods that have been saved—French Park and Floral Park, for example—got lucky. They were separate entities to begin with, and they survived because of the tireless efforts of residents who could afford to buy, say, one house and slowly restore it.

No one can afford to buy a house that belongs to Mike Harrah—one he plans to replace with a 37-story monument to commerce. It's impossible; even more impossible than the recent standoff over the historic Fox Theater in downtown Fullerton. That situation came down to money, too: at the 23rd hour and 59th minute, preservationists got lucky when one anonymous donor wrote a $1 million check. This hasn't happened in Santa Ana, and most likely it won't. The people with the money are Harrah and the city—and they're planning to use that money and their historical buildings to make more money.

* * *

Orange County is like so many other Western municipalities in that it hasn't yet realized its own historical worth. Preservation is piecemeal here, partly because so much of the county was built in the recent past and isn't historic—yet many cities that do have historic areas (Fullerton, Anaheim, Orange and Huntington Beach are classic examples) don't know how to handle them properly and make exceptions for the "right" developers or corporations.

Which brings us back to Santa Ana, where Harrah is the right developer with the right project at the right time—which is to say, it's right for him and it's right for Santa Ana's power brokers. OBP would mint Harrah as a developer; he would no longer be just the guy who won the Santa Ana Historical Preservation Society's annual preservation award in 2003 (the year before suing it over One Broadway Plaza), the guy who restored Santa Ana's three signature historic buildings: the 1929 Santora Building at 207 N. Broadway; the former Masonic Temple, now Santa Ana Performing Arts & Events Center, at 505 N. Sycamore St.; and the 1919 Cadillac dealership, now Original Mike's restaurant, at 100 N. Main St.

Putting OBP over would move Harrah toward the top echelon of Orange County developers. His name would forever be linked to a massive new development—as opposed to restorations. The project also would distance Harrah from his variegated past as the 50-something dude who holds a Screen Actors Guild card and did helicopter stunts in Austin Powers: Goldmember, who was once seen wearing a $26,000 coyote-fur coat, who somewhat mysteriously weathered a $28.5 million bankruptcy in 1990 not caused by purchasing that same coat, and who rides a Harley and lives in Newport.

Harrah would finally be able to trade history for progress. That sounds odd given his own recent past, but maybe that's what he's really been trying to do this whole time. Progress may not look as good as history, but it pays better—much better than any chain of events that involves saving the McNeill-Basler house and the Yale Apartments.

And this isn't just about Harrah. OBP also would let Santa Ana reassert its supremacy as the county seat, which has been in jeopardy since the day several months ago that UC Irvine first suggested moving the state appellate court building from its teeny, ancient quarters in Santa Ana to new digs on its campus—a threat Santa Ana has now beaten back.

"This is about the future of Santa Ana and Orange County," Harrah told the Santa Ana City Council last summer, shortly before midnight, on the night it approved One Broadway Plaza, sparking the signature drive that led to Measure A. OBP, Harrah continued, in a voice that rumbled like his Harley, would make Santa Ana "a place to go, not a place to go through." His words must have spread like a salve over the city's inferiority complex—its worries of losing claim to the title of "county seat," of not having a world-class mall, of being a city of working-class minorities. It seemed clear that, if built, One Broadway Plaza would let Santa Ana keep its lawyers, their money and their prestige. Harrah has said before that he would rent OBP to attorneys. And he would make far more from a new commercial space than he ever would from two residential properties.

This is all about money, and no one with money is interested in saving either structure—so they sit, moldering into disrepair. The seminal Yale Apartments is fenced off and boarded up. Its rear staircase is even roofed over so homeless can't sleep on the landing, which hasn't worked. Ironically, when Harrah bought it, the Yale Apartments was a functioning historic apartment building—not a washed-up has-been. Then-renters lived in a modernist stucco cube that recalled the architect Irving Gill's better efforts. Gill, who tried to link his buildings to the outdoors by painting them white tinged with just a hint of green, might not have liked the Yale's current slate blue, but he surely would have approved of its interior, which is perhaps its best-known feature.

Much of the Yale's insides are sheathed in rare gumwood, an exotic that is threatened because builders long ago used up most of it—and hearing that, you probably want to tear down the Yale yourself. Bastards,howdaretheyuseupallthegumwoodtrees?

But the only way to save the gumwood—aside from not using any more of it—is to save buildings that are repositories of it, like the Yale, which looks as if it's clad in "plastic liquid amber," according to those who have seen inside. Harrah, who wants the land for OBP, doesn't care if the Yale has gumwood interior accents or original skylights—which it does. According to the city, he had an inspector declare it seismically unsound, which gave him pretext to evict its tenants and board the place up. Santa Ana, which supports OBP, stepped in at the last minute to save it from immediate demolition (the city is fine with demolition done through the proper channels) and to broker a deal that would satisfy preservationists.

"He has a standing offer to anybody who wants any of those buildings that are in the [way]," says Kenneth Adams, Santa Ana's assistant director of planning and building. The offer, Adams says, is to sell it for $1, making it sound as if anyone in the world could buy the Yale Apartments—but then they'd have to pay to move them. According to a feasibility report done several years ago by San Francisco's Garavaglia Architecture, moving the Yale Apartments would cost anywhere from $200,000 to half a million dollars.

"It would probably have cost more per square foot to move than to build," Adams says, adding, "We haven't had a move, we haven't processed one in about 10 years." Harrah wouldn't talk to us for this article, but Adams says his $1 offer also applies to the McNeill-Basler house two doors north, where its success would be equally doubtful. Moving unreinforced brick buildings is always tricky—though it goes without saying that moving the McNeill-Basler house has never come up before. (Preservationists say that if it is saved, one use under discussion is renovating it into a Marie Callendar's restaurant.) Built by famed Orange County contractor Christopher McNeill, who also built the original Orange County courthouse, it passed down in 1948 to Dr. Herman Basler, its third owner. Basler bought it from a real-estate financier and ran a convalescent hospital one door south of his stately three-story home, with its pointed, Gothic window frames; ornately cut eaves; huge master bath with two sinks; and downstairs fireplace big enough to roast a suckling pig. All this would have to be relocated.

1
 
2
 
All
 
Next Page »
 
My Voice Nation Help
 
Loading...